Critics of proposed Manitoba silica sand mine applaud environmental report that casts doubt on challenge basic safety

Critics of proposed Manitoba silica sand mine applaud environmental report that casts doubt on challenge basic safety

A new environmental report on a proposed large-scale silica sand mining operation in southern Manitoba suggests it should really only move forward soon after the province gets more lawful assistance and there is a greater knowledge of possible challenges, whilst some argue the province has all the proof it wants to get rid of the project now.

The Clean up Surroundings Fee report out Friday features 8 suggestions concerning a proposal by Sio Silica that has stirred debate in the rural municipality of Springfield, just east of Winnipeg.

The Alberta-primarily based enterprise would like to drill up to 7,700 wells throughout east and southeastern Manitoba to extract pure silica sand. 

“The commission does not have enough self-assurance that the stage of danger posed to an essential supply of ingesting h2o for the location has been sufficiently outlined,” reads a part of the 105-web page doc launched by the Clean Natural environment Fee, an arms-length provincial agency mandated to provide tips and tips to Manitoba’s ecosystem minister.

“The mining solution proposed by Sio Silica does have merit if the threats posed to the good quality of drinking water in the affected aquifers can be superior defined and the management of those people threats can be adequately addressed.”

Its authors suggest the project should only push on if the province imposes significant conditions on mining action.

A woman with shoulder-length gray hair wearing a blue shirt stands in front of a garden while speaking to a reporter.
Tangi Bell is president of Our Line in the Sand, a group that has advocated against the Sio Silica sand mining operation proposed in japanese Manitoba. (Travis Golby/CBC)

Tangi Bell, president of Our Line in the Sand, a group that has advocated against the task, stated the commission should’ve long gone even even more.

“They did not strongly recommend to deny, prohibit this task, and that is what it really should be executing,” she claimed.

“It does not have benefit. This is the most unethical undertaking that I’ve at any time found deemed. It should really hardly ever have been viewed as, should never have been tabled, it should’ve been thrown out appropriate from the get-go.”

The Manitoba federal government should request authorized impression on how the proposed strategies harmonize with things of the Groundwater and Water Perfectly Act and the Mines and Minerals Act concerning the implications of drilling and extraction, the report states.

Adhering to that, if the venture can go ahead legally, the fee endorses extra scientific, engineering and danger assessments be completed.

Only then should it progress “on a phase-smart foundation to enhance the amount of self-confidence that no sizeable adverse results will take place to impair the good quality and quantity of h2o accessible from the impacted aquifers.”

“As a standard principle, comprehensive-scale generation really should only carry on if and when the entire body of scientific and engineering evidence confirms that the hazards are sufficiently comprehended and workable,” reads a person of a number of tips.

Watch | What silica mining critics fear:

What silica mining critics panic

What critics worry could take place if silica mining in southeastern Manitoba is approved.

The fee was predicted to deliver its report to government this week as 1 of the final opportunity hurdles to Alberta-based mostly Sio Silica’s proposed mining operations in east and southeast Manitoba, which contains plans to extract 22 million tonnes of extremely-pure silica sand positioned 50 metres down.

Silica is utilized in the output of solar panels, semiconductors and new batteries. Sio Silica proposes drilling down and piping out a sand-h2o slurry that would be despatched to a processing facility, which would then address the water and re-inject it back again into the floor. 

A single recommendation from Friday’s report would involve the enterprise to demonstrate how that re-injection approach would do the job.

The report now goes to Manitoba Environment Minister Kevin Klein, who will have final say.

Atmosphere minister to decide

Klein stated for the duration of a Friday information convention the province will assessment the report, which could consider time.

“We will shift at the speed that our environmental experts and our committee folks will need to go.… No selection will be built until the entire system is concluded thoroughly,” Klein explained.

“This is a contentious challenge, and it is contentious mainly because of protection,” he claimed. “The basic safety of Manitobans’ drinking drinking water will come initially.”

The fee endorses Klein strike a project-checking committee with senior officials in just Manitoba’s setting and weather ministry, together with technical gurus from provincial mining, groundwater, environmental licensing and enforcement divisions, as perfectly as council users from suitable municipalities.

A handful of sand.
Silica is used in the generation of photo voltaic panels, semiconductors and new batteries. (Gary Solilak/CBC)

That committee really should be envisioned to share growth monitoring studies with the community, the commission stated.

Sio Silica reported in a statement it recognizes the time and energy the Thoroughly clean Setting Commission set into the evaluate of its proposal.

The corporation is “committed to continuous exploration, details analysis, operational improvements, environmental checking and partnerships with Manitoba corporations,” Sio Silica companion Sander Duncanson claimed in a statement.

The company aims to be “the world’s most environmentally helpful producer of superior purity silica,” the assertion extra.

Mining concerns some citizens

The mining ideas have drawn the ire of some citizens and neighborhood elected officers. Concerns in the neighborhood largely relate to the probability of groundwater contamination from drilling.

A woman holds up a sign of drop of water with the text that reads 'Save our water.'
Jackie Mazur, who has lived in the rural municipality of Springfield for most of her life, holds up a signal that reads ‘Save our water’ on Monday outside the house the RM council offices in Oakbank, Person. (Bryce Hoye/CBC)

Some people and councillors in the rural municipality of Springfield voiced considerations at two council meetings in the previous two months. 

On Monday, the RM council voted through zoning amendments desired in get for Sio Silica’s proposed processing plant to be constructed in the local community of Vivian.

But a motion to enter into a progress settlement with the corporation did not move, sending discussions among council and Sio Silica back to the drawing desk.

Sio Silica has reported the operation would not damage the surroundings and could convey in billions of dollars to Manitoba’s overall economy.

‘Worst-situation scenario’ 

Amid the other Clean up Natural environment Commission report tips are a stipulation Sio Silica carry out a chance evaluation that considers “worst-scenario eventualities” — including collapse of the limestone layer — and the feasible ripple results and remediation efforts of individuals eventualities. 

Sio Silica need to also accomplish exams that incorporate to the human body of evidence on threat to guarantee a “bigger level of self-assurance” in the environmental basic safety of the challenge, which include probable pitfalls associated with proposed drilling techniques, the report states.

Check out | How the mining procedure would do the job:

How the mining would perform

How Sio Silica hopes to extract sand from down below the floor of southeastern Manitoba.

It also suggests the enterprise carry out total-scale extraction tests on a person proposed properly cluster in unique, targeting 21,000 tonnes of sand.

Extraction test wells need to be monitored for adjust for the duration of drilling as a way of estimating how very likely cavities are to improve in shape and sizing in excess of time, the report states.

Sio Silica must also develop drinking water and waste administration programs, perfectly modification designs, groundwater checking and mitigation plans, erosion and sediment manage prepare, environmental emergency reaction plans and additional, it says.

The commission also needs an assessment on the cumulative consequences of the operation around its predicted 24-calendar year span in just the context of other present and long run projects in the location.

NDP, environmental group applaud report

That the proposal didn’t include items like a cumulative effects report signals the province did not inquire for it, and it should “in no way have handed the original division of surroundings and weather display screen,” according to the Manitoba Eco-Community and Our Line in the Sand.

“It is time to set a end to this shoddy, piecemeal technique to assessing these types of a huge and dangerous job that will affect thousands of people for many years to appear,” the teams, represented by the General public Fascination Regulation Centre, claimed in a assertion.

A map of southeastern Manitoba, showing Winnipeg and mineral claims to the east, southeast and south of the city.
The parts in yellow demarcate Sio Silica’s subsurface mineral promises in southern Manitoba, according to paperwork filed with Manitoba’s Clean Setting Fee. (CBC News Graphics)

The statement asks Klein to reject the licensing proposal until finally environmental hazards are much more absolutely regarded as, and to not entertain it again right up until the organization has complied with all eight of the commission’s suggestions.

The Opposition NDP said the report helps make distinct there are authentic considerations encompassing the proposal as it stands and mirrored Klein’s sentiments in excess of the will need to “take time to get it proper.”

“With just two months away from an election marketing campaign, Premier [Heather] Stefanson and Minister Klein should dedicate to adhering to the caretaker conference and refrain from making any final final decision on this venture right before the up coming federal government is decided on,” NDP MLA Mark Wasyliw (Fort Garry) claimed in a assertion.

Liberal Leader Dougald Lamont (St. Boniface) stated he thinks the governing administration wants the project to shift ahead, but it should really as a substitute close the course of action now.

“Professionals in drinking water, they have said this has hardly ever been finished just before, they can not figure out how to do it with out owning sinkholes,” he mentioned.

“We basically have great deposits of sand somewhere else which are now staying mined devoid of getting to set our biggest aquifer at threat.”

Related posts